Jacobin - April 16, 2019
Last week, Donald Trump amplified a racist smear against a sitting Democratic lawmaker, potentially endangering her life.
With a few exceptions — including Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren, who were both quick to release strongly worded statements, as did several House members — the initial responses offered by some Democrats, including several of those currently seeking the party’s 2020 presidential nomination, ranged from gutless to downright appalling.
On Thursday, the right-wing New York Postpublished a cover boasting an out-of-context quote from Minnesota representative Ilhan Omar in a nakedly cynical attempt to imply she was trivializing the September 11, 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center. Taken from a March speech at the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) in which Omar discussed the prejudices experienced by Muslim Americans, here’s the quote in context:
Here’s the truth: far too long we have lived with the discomfort of being a second-class citizen. And frankly I’m tired of it, and every single Muslim in this country should be tired of it. CAIR was founded after 9/11, because they recognized that some people did something and then all of us were starting to lose access to our civil liberties.
Following quickly on the heels of the Post’s bigoted cover, Donald Trump tweeted an edited video superimposing Omar over 9/11 imagery with the caption “WE WILL NEVER FORGET!” A veritable army of other right-wing figures quickly followed suit.
These more or less explicit attempts to link Omar, a Muslim woman — and by extension Muslims in general — to terrorism should have provoked both swift condemnation and unequivocal expressions of solidarity with the congresswoman from leading figures in the opposition.
Or so you’d think.
Failing to even mention Omar let alone come to her defense, House majority leader Nancy Pelosi’s initial statement instead accused Trump of misappropriating the memory of 9/11. Following a backlash, Pelosi eventually released a second statement that actually referred to the congresswoman by name. And while said backlash may have played a role in inspiring other leading Democrats to speak, many of their initial responses proved little better.
Copying Pelosi’s template, liberal media darling Beto O’Rourke also failed to mention Omar as the target of the president’s attack. Amy Klobuchar’s statement, meanwhile, seemed to imply there had, in fact, been something wrong with Omar’s remarks, needlessly including the addendum: “You can disagree with her words — as I have done before — but this video is wrong.” Likewise, Kirsten Gillibrand’s response outrageously suggested that Omar had “minimized the pain of 9/11 victims.” True to form, Joe Biden said absolutely nothing. (The Intercept’s Robert Mackey has collected every response from Democratic presidential contenders here, including various amended second attempts.)
While there’s plenty of competition these days, it’s difficult to imagine a starker illustration of Democratic fecklessness than the combination of foot-dragging, equivocation, and vaguery that initially followed the Right’s latest onslaught against Omar. Faced with an example of the Trump presidency at its ugliest — in the form of a racist incitement campaign aimed at one of their own colleagues, no less — it took days for some to even utter a word, and a few still tried to have it both ways: condemning Trump’s rhetoric in the abstract while maintaining a safe distance from Omar herself.
It hardly needs saying, but meekness and vacillation of this kind will only further embolden the Right. If Trump is determined to use a congresswoman and her words to attack Muslim Americans, the only adequate response is to defend both without hesitation.